Charges · Theft · Ontario
What happens after a theft under $5,000 charge in Ontario?
What it means, what usually happens next, and what to bring to the first call.
Or chat by textTalk it through — the line answers and your file opens while you talk.
or call +1 289-367-7860
- Free
- Private
- No pressure
- Canadian
In short
- Theft under $5,000 covers shoplifting and most small thefts; many first-time charges in Ontario end without a criminal record through diversion.
- The store’s own ban letter and a civil demand letter are separate from the criminal charge.
- A first court date in 4–6 weeks; the Crown screens the file; first-time, low-value cases are often offered a diversion program (community service, a donation, a course).
What usually happens next
- Often first
A call from an investigator Theft cases often start with a detective’s call, sometimes days or weeks after the events, asking the person to come in.
- At the station
Arrest by appointment Attending usually means an arrest on arrival. There is a right to stay silent and to speak to a lawyer privately.
- Same visit
Fingerprints and a photo Fingerprints and a photo are usually taken, either that day or on a date listed on the papers.
- A few hours in
Release papers Most people charged with theft are released the same day, with papers setting a first court date and any conditions.
- From signing
Conditions about people and places Conditions may bar contact with the complainant, or visits to a store or workplace. They apply once they are signed.
What should you bring to the first call?
How it works in Ontario
Which court hears it in Ontario
A theft charge in Ontario begins in the Ontario Court of Justice; the court says about 95% of these charges are also completed there. Ontario lists every criminal courthouse, with its daily court lists, on ontario.ca, so the court date on the release paper can be checked against the list.
Bail in Ontario
If someone is held on an Ontario theft charge, the Crown’s D. 24 directive says the amount promised must be within the means of the accused and the surety, and that release conditions must not be used to punish.
Programs and diversion in Ontario
Ontario’s Direct Accountability Program, run in most Ontario jurisdictions under the Crown’s D. 4 directive, is one community justice program a theft file can be referred to. The prosecutor may refer any offence not excluded by the directive, if a conviction is reasonably likely.
The local process in Ontario
Legal Aid Ontario pays for a lawyer where a charge could lead to jail and the person qualifies financially; duty counsel can hold a resolution meeting with the Crown on the court day.
What do we see with theft charges?
Most theft charges are “under $5,000,” and most people charged have never been in a police station. The first call is about two things: the release paper, and any ban from the store. If your release papers bar you from the store, going back is a breach and a new charge. A store’s own ban letter is separate; ignoring it can lead to a trespass ticket. The file opens while you talk.
What do people ask about theft charges?
What should I bring?
Bring every paper the police gave you (release order, undertaking, appearance notice); photo ID; the names of anyone who saw what happened; any texts, photos or messages about it.
Do I have to talk to the police?
No — a person does not have to answer police questions, whether that’s in person, at a station, or over the phone. You can confirm identifying information if asked, but you’re not required to explain, discuss the events, or answer follow-up questions.
What usually happens after a theft charge?
A lawyer asks about that before anything else.
Who prosecutes this charge in Ontario?
In Ontario, a Crown attorney from Ontario’s Ministry of the Attorney General prosecutes this charge, and the case starts in the Ontario Court of Justice. Jury trials in Ontario are held in the Superior Court of Justice.
Is there a diversion program in Ontario?
Ontario’s Crown Prosecution Manual names the Direct Accountability Program, in place in most Ontario jurisdictions, as one community justice program. In Ontario the prosecutor decides whether a case is referred, and only where there is a reasonable prospect of conviction. A person in it must accept responsibility for what led to the charge and be prepared to make meaningful amends.
Who speaks for the prosecution at a bail hearing in Ontario?
Most bail hearings in Ontario are held in the Ontario Court of Justice, with a Crown attorney speaking for the prosecution.
Sources
Ontario sources
- Ontario Court of Justice, criminal court overview, accessed October 15, 2026
- Ontario court locations and daily court lists, accessed October 8, 2026
- Ontario Crown Prosecution Manual, D. 24 Judicial Interim Release (Bail), accessed October 14, 2026
- Ontario Crown Prosecution Manual, D. 4 Community Justice Programs for Adults, accessed October 8, 2026
- Legal Aid Ontario, criminal legal issues, accessed October 15, 2026
- Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General, diversion, accessed September 22, 2026
- Steps to Justice (CLEO), shoplifting, accessed September 22, 2026
Federal law sources
- Criminal Code (Canada), ss. 322, 334, accessed September 22, 2026
Free 24/7 criminal law information · not legal advice. Legal Aid Ontario: 1-800-668-8258
- PIPEDACanadian privacy law
- EncryptedIn transit and at rest
- Your yes firstNothing saved without it
- No card. No SIN.Never asked
- Kept while openThen deleted
- CanadianOwned and built here
Remandly is not a law firm and does not give legal advice. Free 24/7 criminal law information.
